Potato Gnocchi With Tomato Basil Sauce

May 7, 2020 by Marisa 42 Comments

In this dish, Potato Gnocchi with Tomato Basil Sauce, the humble potato is transformed into a melt-in-your mouth delicacy. Just about any sauce will compliment potato gnocchi.

What are Gnocchi?

Gnocchi are simply the Italian version of potato dumplings and can be prepared in limitless ways.

Today, there is such an extensive variety of gnocchi! Some are made with ricotta or squash while others are flavoured with beets.

There are also gnocchi where different flours are utilized, such as chestnut, buckwheat and also wholewheat flour.

Another version is made with semolina flour, milk, cheese and known as Gnocchi alla Romana.

These Potato Gnocchi with Tomato Basil Sauce, however, is the type of dish I grew up with.

They were my number one request each time mamma would ask me what I wanted to eat for my birthday celebration. She never failed to remind me of the countless times I would help her twirl the gnocchi with my chubby little fingers!

How To Make Potato Gnocchi From Scratch

Start with a starchy potato such as the russet potato and you can either boil them or bake them in the oven.

Just make sure not to pierce or cut through the potato when boiling them, otherwise they will absorb too much water.

You can easily mash the potatoes with a fork but a potato ricer really does an excellent job of mashing the potatoes and it’s a good investment for one who often makes gnocchi.

Mix the mashed potatoes with the beaten egg, salt and work in some flour with your hands.

Knead the dough for a few minutes while working in a little more flour if sticking too much on your hands and work surface. It should be soft and pliable.

How To Shape Gnocchi

Working with one piece of dough at a time, roll the gnocchi dough into a 1/2 rope then cut into 1 inch pieces.

To shape the gnocchi, you can use a handy wooden gnocchi board but if you don’t have one, no worries!

I was taught to twirl the gnocchi using my index finger and middle finger by pressing both down into the gnocchi and rolling quickly towards me.

Alternately you can use the back of a fork to make the pretty indentations. The little ridges that form are a perfect entrapment for all that delicious sauce.

Tips for Making Potato Gnocchi From Scratch

Always start with less amount of flour than the recipe calls for. The moisture of your potatoes and the amount of eggs used will determine how much flour is needed.

Do not knead more than a few minutes as this would result in too much flour adsorption which yields heavier gnocchi.

It goes without saying to always use a big sauce pot when cooking any form of pasta. Drop a few at a time into the boiling water to avoid the gnocchi from sticking together.

Ideally you will want to make and cook the gnocchi within a few hours. Simply transfer the gnocchi in a single layer on a lightly dusted cookie sheet and cover with a clean dish towel till ready to use.

Gnocchi can also be frozen. Transfer them on a cookie sheet in a single layer and place the tray in the freezer. Once frozen, transfer them into a freezer bag.

These exquisite potato gnocchi are very filling and therefore often served in moderate portions as a first course meal.

You’ll want to savour every bite! Enjoy the melt-in-your mouth sensation and never rush a good thing.

Above all, have fun and enjoy the process. After all practice makes perfect!

This recipe was originally published Sept. 14 2016 and updated May 7, 2020 with new photos and content.

Print Pin

3 from 2 votes